The Milburn Review ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation’ has rightly looked at how we can reset the system to support young people into meaningful employment. Its focus on a greater package of support to help young people into work is welcome. However, if the recommendations to remove eligibility for the Universal Credit (UC) ‘health element’ replace support with a lower value alternative, this risks pushing vulnerable young people into poverty while doing little to improve their chances of finding work.
Universal Credit (UC) ‘health element’
The health element of UC is an additional payment for claimants with mental and physical health needs that impact their ability to work. Claimants will have complex needs and have undergone a Work Capability Assessment (WCA) conducted by a health professional.
WCAs are often seen as inadequate in assessing claimants’ mental health needs, and the young people who are able to qualify due to mental illness will often have particularly complex needs. Any proposals to remove or reduce this support are likely to rely in part on the same assessment system, risking further disadvantage for young people with mental health conditions whose needs are already poorly recognised and who may struggle to access appropriate support.
Many young people receiving this support are not currently well enough to work. The Department for Work and Pensions’ own research suggests that just 13% of young people under 25 receiving a disability benefit think they would be able to work – even if the right job and support were available. This does not mean they will never be able to work, but that they need time, stability and appropriate support to improve their health.
For young people with a mental illness, this additional money is vital. It enables them to manage their health, engage with support, and have greater independence, all of which can promote participation in society. Removing financial support makes this much harder.
Removing UC ‘health element’ will damage young people’s mental health
Less financial security for young people with a mental illness would push vulnerable young people into poverty, reducing their chances of recovery or employment.
Citizens Advice found that, even before the new lower rate of the Universal Credit (UC) ‘health element’ was introduced last year, almost one in three people who contacted them about the UC health element needed help with crisis support, and more than one quarter needed advice on debt.
A further loss of support could be devastating. In fact, Action for Children estimates that 94% of households with a young person under 22 claiming the UC health element would be in poverty if the support were cut.
This additional insecurity will worsen young people’s mental health. Financial security creates the foundations needed to improve mental health and helps people move towards work. Greater insecurity will increase stress and anxiety created by financial pressures, including from debt and housing difficulties. It will also make it harder to afford essentials such as food, heating, medication and travel. These pressures not only affect mental health but also create barriers to receiving support and to getting and maintaining work.
Removing the UC ‘health element’ will have a limited impact:
As well as making the material situation worse for young people, removing the UC health element from this group would save only a fraction of overall Universal Credit spending. Action for Children found that under-22s account for only 3% of UC health element claims and only 5% of spending. While it can deliver some modest savings, it could potentially create significant additional costs across the public sector due to the increase in poverty and harm to the mental health of young people.
There also has not been a significant rise in the number of young people claiming this support. The proportion of 16–21-year-olds claiming a work-related disability benefit was the same in 2025 as it was in 2015, at around 2% of the population. This suggests those claiming the UC health element are not the main driving factor for the recent increase in the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEETs) or that the increase in NEETs is driving a rise in claims for the UC health element.
Removing this support would therefore do little to address the wider rise in youth economic inactivity or the pressure on the welfare system. Instead, it would take vital financial support away from a relatively small group of young people whose health or disability means they will often be unable to work soon.
Additional support will not offset the impact of cutting financial support:
Alan Milburn described hearing from young people who feel trapped in the benefits system. He is right that the system should not leave them feeling this way. The Review’s commitment to investment in employment and mental health support before benefit changes is important. But sequencing alone will not protect a young person whose regular income falls under the replacement system. The test is whether support is genuinely available when needed and whether young people retain the financial security to use it, including those who remain unable to work for a prolonged period.
While the additional mental health support recommended in the Review is very welcome, its benefits will be limited if some young people are simultaneously made materially worse off, even in the short term. Alongside the practical barriers to accessing support created by poverty, young people have described shame and embarrassment about poverty and mental ill health. Some have felt unable to discuss their financial difficulties with friends or professionals. This can prevent them from opening up to mental health workers and engaging fully with support, potentially worsening their mental health over time.
Similarly, plans to expand support through the Youth Guarantee may improve access to employment, education and training opportunities, but they will not address the financial barriers that prevent some young people from taking part in these schemes.
Even in employment, young people may not benefit immediately. Current employment opportunities can lack stability or security, and many may end up under-employed or working way below their potential to earn a proper living. This can be particularly difficult for young people with poor mental health. Some young people will still rely on additional financial support – like Access to Work – to pay for transport, equipment and care so they can continue to work and often struggle to make ends meet.
Even if these reforms improve outcomes for young people overall and help more into work, some will remain unable to work in the short term. For many with complex mental health needs, work will not be possible for some time. Losing financial support would leave them significantly worse off in the meantime.
Build instead of cutting the foundations:
The Review is right to want to improve employment outcomes for young people. However, employment support is only effective when built on strong foundations, including good health and financial security. By protecting the financial support provided by the UC health element while investing in mental health support, employment opportunities and a stronger Youth Guarantee, the Government can give young people the best chance to recover and then participate and thrive. Over time, this approach can reduce reliance on support such as the UC health element. Cutting support too soon risks achieving the opposite: it will make young people poorer and damage their mental health further.
Protecting this safety net does not mean preserving a system that too often fails to recognise mental health needs. We are open to a new form of support, provided it maintains entitlement and the value of financial support while better meeting young people’s needs. But reform that leaves young people worse off risks harming those it should help. Any replacement must also understand the shortcomings of assessments in the current system, not repeat them.
Ultimately, the test of reform should be whether it gives young people the security, support and opportunities they need to recover and achieve greater independence, not if it reduces the number of people receiving financial support.
Written by Gregory Kay, Public Affairs Advisor, The Children and Young People’s Coalition





